Real
Pizza.
Retro
Vibes.
Detroit-Style, Deep Dish & New York Pizza Plus Italian Gelato — Serving Sanibel & Captiva, FL
Detroit-style and New York pizza made fresh daily. Grab a slice for takeout or pull up to our outdoor hightop seating and enjoy the island breeze.
Delivery from $14.99 + 18% driver gratuity — or skip fees with free pickup
Our Location
Now open on Sanibel Island
Scooters Pizza
2496 Palm Ridge RdSanibel, FL 33957Get DirectionsHours
Our Pizza
Two island residents bringing the best of both worlds to Sanibel Island.
Detroit-Style
A rectangular, thick-crust pizza baked in blue steel pans. The dough is airy and crispy on the bottom with caramelized cheese edges called "frico." Sauce goes on top, making every bite perfectly balanced.
New York-Style
Classic hand-tossed pies in true 16" and massive 24" sizes — thin, foldable, and packed with flavor. The way pizza was meant to be eaten.
Thin Crust
Our thin crust option delivers a crispy, cracker-like base that lets the toppings shine. Perfect for those who prefer less dough and more flavor in every bite.
Gluten Free
Great pizza should be for everyone. Our gluten-free crust is made with care so you can enjoy all the flavor without compromise. Available in select sizes.
Why We're Different
Fast Delivery
Our central location delivers everywhere on Sanibel and Captiva.
Fresh Ingredients
Dough made daily. Sauce from scratch. No shortcuts.
Island Vibes
Born on the beach, baked for the locals.
Featured Pizza
Miles of Pepperoni
Layers of crispy cup & char pepperoni piled high on a bed of our signature red sauce and a rich mozzarella & provolone blend, crowned with pillowy clouds of burrata filling, freshly grated Romano, torn basil, and a sweet-heat drizzle of hot honey that ties every bite together. Bold, cheesy, and absolutely unforgettable.
What's On It
Order It Your Way
Geno's Giant 12" Slice
Our massive foot-long slice customized with your favorite toppings!
Available Monday–Friday until 3 PM — or until sold out
Meats
- Pepperoni
- Italian Sausage
- Bacon
- Ham
- Anchovies
Premium Meats
- White Meat Chicken
- Italian Meatball
- Buffalo Chicken
- Philly Steak
Veggies
- Fresh Mushrooms
- Jalapeños
- Green Peppers
- Banana Peppers
- White & Red Onion
- Black Olives
- Pineapple
- Basil
Extra Cheeses
- Burrata Filling
- "Stracciatella"
- Ricotta
- Feta Cheese
Flavored Edge
- Butter
- Garlic Butter
- Hot Honey
- Cajun
- Sesame Seed
- Spanish Origin EVOO
- Scooters Crust
- (Romano-Garlic-Butter)
Drizzles
- Hot Honey
- Garlic Oil
- Truffle Oil
- Red Pepper Oil
- Balsamic Drizzle
Why Order Direct
Order straight from us — by phone or through our own online menu — and you'll get the freshest, fastest pizza while keeping more in the pockets of your local Sanibel shop.
Freshest & Fastest
Your order goes straight to our kitchen — no middleman delays, so it's made fresh and out the door faster.
Best Value
Skip the extra third-party markups and service fees. Ordering direct means a better price for you.
Support Local
Every direct order supports a locally owned island shop and the people who make your pizza.
Delivery from $14.99 + 18% driver gratuity — or skip fees with free pickup
Come Taste The Hype!
The pizza is just getting started — come see what everyone's talking about.
Order OnlineFrequently Asked Questions
Everything you need to know about pizza, hours, and ordering on Sanibel Island.
What are your hours?
We're open every day: Sunday 12 PM to 10:30 PM, Monday through Thursday 10:30 AM to 10:30 PM, Friday 10:30 AM to 11 PM, and Saturday 11 AM to 11 PM. Our Geno's Giant 12" slices are available Monday through Friday until 3 PM, or until sold out.
Where are you located and do you deliver?
We're at 2496 Palm Ridge Rd, Sanibel, FL 33957. Our central location lets us deliver across Sanibel and Captiva.
What styles of pizza do you make?
We make Detroit-style deep dish, New York hand-tossed pies (16" and a massive 24"), and a light, crispy thin crust. You'll also find authentic super-premium gelato, baked loaded fries, and more.
Do you have gluten-free options?
Yes! We offer a 12" gluten-free crust made with care so everyone can enjoy great pizza. It's available in select sizes — just ask when you order.
How do I place an order?
Order online any time through our menu, or call us directly at 239-497-4992. Ordering direct gets you the freshest, fastest pizza and supports our local shop.
Is there parking?
Yes, we have convenient parking right at our Palm Ridge Rd location, plus outdoor hightop seating so you can enjoy your pizza with the island breeze.
Is there a delivery fee?
Yes, delivery fees start at $14.99, and an 18% driver gratuity is automatically added to delivery orders.
Get Text Updates
Be the first to know about daily specials, new menu items, and exclusive deals — straight to your phone.
By submitting this form and signing up for texts, you consent to receive text messages (e.g. Registration reminders, enrollment information, Promotions and general updates) from Scooters Pizza at the number provided, including messages sent by autodialer. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP to any message or by contacting us at 239-497-4992. Reply HELP for help. View our full SMS terms & privacy policy.